“That’s Not How We Do It at My Other House”
Suppose your nine-year-old stares at the Thanksgiving table. “At my other house, we eat at noon, and we have ham, not turkey,” she says. “Why is yours different?” She does not sound angry. She sounds like she is checking which family has the right answer.
Biological family holiday traditions often reach your table this way, as a casual question with a lot underneath it. Maybe she lives in your foster home, joined your family through adoption, or splits weekends between your house and her mother’s after a divorce. In every case, you may feel a small sting. You spent days planning this meal, and now she is comparing it to another one. Her question is not a complaint, but it can feel like one.
Thanksgiving starts a season of holidays. You may hear the question come back numerous times over the next few months, whether at Hanukkah, Christmas, Kwanzaa, or New Year’s.
The Question Under the Question
When a child asks about the difference between traditions, she likely is asking about something bigger. She may want to know whether she has permission to love both families without hurting either one. Researchers have studied this painful feeling of being caught mostly in divorce and stepfamilies. Their findings, however, likely apply to all our Plan B families.
What the Research Says About Feeling Caught
A 2003 interview study of 30 stepfamilies looked at children who felt caught between their custodial and noncustodial parents. Blurred communication boundaries between the households exacerbated that feeling. A 1996 article by one of three researchers who followed more than 500 adolescents after their parents divorced points the same way. Adolescents who experienced loyalty conflicts were more depressed and had more behavior problems. They said three things made them feel torn between their parents: adults asked them to carry messages, quizzed them about the other home, or put down the other parent in front of them.
The foster care picture has less gloomy research. A 2016 Dutch study surveyed 59 children, ages 10 to 18, in long-term foster care. On average, they felt loyal and attached to both their foster parents and their birth parents. The children did not see the two sets of parents as rivals. Children who saw any of their parents as more vulnerable felt worse. The sample was small, and the placements were long. This may not fit a child in her first holiday season with you.
Put these together, and a pattern seems to emerge that fits with the experiences I’ve heard kids express. Feeling caught seems to come less from having two families than from what adults do about it.
Why Family Traditions Matter to Children
Traditions matter to our kids. A 2002 review of 32 publications linked family routines and rituals to parenting competence, child adjustment, and marital satisfaction. In a 2002 press release, the reviewers cautioned that healthy, low-conflict families may simply keep their rituals going. The rituals may not cause the good outcomes.
A 2022 survey of 709 Japanese parents linked annual family events to more prosocial behavior in fifth graders. Parents reported everything at one point in time. A 1992 study of 77 families found a related pattern. Adolescents felt less belonging when they and their mothers disagreed about how much ritual the family had.
These studies did not look at our exact Plan B families, but the principles involved would seem to apply just as strongly.
What the Research Says About Contact with Biological Families
Contact with biological families has its own research, and it favors quality over quantity. A 2018 Norwegian study of 203 foster children tested visit frequency. More frequent visits with biological family did not change the children’s psychosocial functioning, their attachment to foster parents, or foster parent stress. The authors suggested that social workers weigh the quality of visits and the child’s own reactions, not only how often visits happen.
In adoption, a 2013 article on a long-running project looked at contact with birth relatives. Satisfaction with that contact predicted better adjustment in adolescents and emerging adults. The project’s own summary of its findings adds two points. Openness alone did not predict adjustment. Collaboration between adoptive and birth families, in cases with contact, did predict better adjustment in middle childhood.
What Seems to Help
The best-supported advice tells us what to avoid. The rest comes from practice.
- Keep her out of the middle. The divorce findings give the clearest list. Do not send messages through her, quiz her about the other home, or put down the other parent. That list applies to every Plan B parent, even when you disagree with how the other family celebrates.
- Welcome the other family’s traditions as part of who she is. In a 2018 Spanish study of 26 foster children and 39 foster parents, children adjusted better when foster parents supported the tie to the birth family. Hostility toward the birth family made adjustment harder and raised the risk that the placement would fall apart. The sample was small, but it is in line with other research about collaboration between biological and Plan B parents.
- Ask, then add. A FosterClub guide advises asking about the holiday traditions the child knew before foster care and, if possible, making room for them in your own celebration. Another guide for foster parents suggests asking what she remembers about the food, music, and parties in her birth family, and staying open to including those traditions in yours.
- Expect mixed feelings, even when she enjoys your holiday. The same guide warns that a child who has fun with you may feel she betrays her birth parents. Watch for those signs and be ready to reassure your kids that enjoying one family’s traditions isn’t disloyal to the other family.
- Keep some of her earlier rituals. A university extension guide on stepfamily rituals says changing too many of a child’s earlier rituals can raise stress and lower a sense of belonging. It recommends keeping some of those rituals to strengthen a child’s sense of consistency.
- Stay flexible with your own traditions. A stepfamily author’s guide suggests combining, changing, or setting aside old traditions in a given year so new ones can grow.
- Let her parent lead in a stepfamily. In stepfamilies, let the child’s biological parent lead the rituals that belong to the two of them. You can build new traditions alongside them.
Back at the Thanksgiving table, you might say, “That sounds good. What is Thanksgiving like there?” If the child wants, add one small piece, such as the biological family’s ham next to your turkey. If your child says no, you have lost nothing. If he or she says yes, the other family has just become part of your holiday. The same approach fits Hanukkah, Christmas, Kwanzaa, and New Year’s, and it fits a different faith, a different meal, or no holiday at all.
I cannot promise that asking will completely resolve the issue. Some years a child’s question will still ache, for your child and for you. The biological family belongs to your child whether or not we like how they celebrate. Your holiday can leave room for both families. The research cannot promise that collaboration works, but it increases your odds.
Want to go deeper? Our online course, Understanding Trauma in Foster, Adoptive, and Stepchildren helps you recognize and understand trauma responses as you meet the challenges of raising other people’s children.
