“I Wish I Had Different Parents”
The holiday schedule is not settled yet. The relatives have opinions, the other household has plans, and someone in your house is tired of all of it. Then a child looks at you and says, “I wish I had different parents.”
It stings. Foster, adoptive, and stepparents often spend months building toward the day a child lets them in. The sentence can feel like the child just erased all that work.
I never heard that exact sentence from my kids. I did hear its close cousin, “You are not my parent,” from foster children. Either one can make us go quiet and defensive, so it helps to plan before the argument starts.
Why the Holidays Bring It Out
The holidays put a lot of unanswered questions on the table. A foster child eats dinner in a house full of traditions that belong to someone else. A child of divorce may split the day between two homes. A stepchild may watch a new family form around a table that used to look different. An adopted child may think about the people who are not there. Foster children often feel sad when reminders of happy families surround them. Many of our kids may feel guilty and disloyal if they let themselves enjoy a new family. A child who is dealing with any or all of these emotions may say something sharp to the nearest adult.
What the Sentence Can Mean at Different Ages
Research on how young children mean this sentence is thin. If a small child says it, perhaps the best approach is just to answer the feeling gently and skip the debate. Acknowledge that they are in a tough environment and that they are welcome in your family. Sometimes the best you can do is just say, “I’m sorry you miss your parents, and I love you, and I’m glad you are here.”
With teenagers, the research is stronger. A 1997 study of parent and peer conflict found that parent-child conflict most often centers on authority, autonomy, and responsibilities. That study did not focus on Plan B families, but the pattern fits what many of us see. A teenager who says “I wish I had different parents” may mean “I want more say over my own life.” In a stepfamily, a teenager may aim that wish at a stepparent who holds authority without much shared history yet.
What It Can Mean in Our Families
In foster care, a 2016 review of foster children’s views of their birth parents covered several studies. Most of them reported that at least some children yearned for their parents or felt anxious about the separation, even when the parents had been abusive. A child can wish for different parents because the parents the child wants are the ones the child once had and lost.
In adoption, the picture varies. A 2019 study of 81 adopted adolescents found that adoption brings a new family and also inevitable losses. The teens did acknowledge parts of their story that made them sad and angry. Most of them, however, did not identify any losses. Most also showed little curiosity about their origins, apart from wanting to know why the adoption happened. Do not assume your adopted child grieves on a schedule. Some do, and some do not.
In stepfamilies, a 2011 study of 49 adults who grew up as stepchildren found six ways relationships with stepparents developed. The patterns included accepting the stepparent as a parent, accepting with ambivalence, rejecting, and coexisting. Ambivalence fits what I have seen. For the first year of my marriage, my stepsons were friendly, polite, and reserved. Their parents had both been in short relationships after the divorce, so the boys did not know how long I would stay. But all of us eventually found our footing. Years later I asked one stepson whether he had stopped wondering if his father and I would split up. “Pretty much,” he said. “I mean, you are still here.”
Divorce belongs in this conversation too. A 2015 study of adults whose parents divorced notes that children caught in their parents’ conflict tend to adjust less well. That study was a retrospective one and did not follow children as they grew up. Still, it fits what many of us have seen. A child can feel loyal to one home and grateful to another at the same time, and the pull between them hurts. We need to recognize those feelings and not load any more on children than they already face from the divorce itself.
How Not to Take It Personally
I cannot point to research showing that staying calm changes how a child feels. What I can offer is my own record, and it comes down to five habits.
Ask yourself if you are sending the wrong signals. Sometimes a sharp sentence reflects a real hurt. One of my foster children once complained that I liked my nieces and nephews more than I liked her. She was factually wrong, and I knew I could not argue with her reality. When I thought more about it, I realized she was reacting to my stories about those kids, because none of the stories included her. The complaint was an exaggeration, but it pointed at something true that I needed to change. It is always worth asking ourselves what the child might be seeing.
Stop defending yourself. More than one foster child told me, “You are not my parent.” They were right. I was not their parent, and I never could be. My answer is the same one I would give to “I wish I had different parents.” We are the adult who is there, who cares about them, and whose job is to take care of them. I start by telling the child I am sorry the other parent is not here, and I say I care about them.
Stay out of the middle. When I was a new foster parent, I hovered within earshot of my foster children’s phone calls with their parents. A more experienced foster parent told me I could not protect the children from their parents’ words. She said I was only damaging my relationship with them. A child who says something raw to you is not asking you to referee. The child usually is asking for a second opinion or support, not a champion.
Follow the child’s lead. Children sometimes use us as a sounding board for their conflicts with their biological parents. I tried to help them reach their own conclusions without offering advice. I often failed at that. When I followed their lead, however, our relationship always grew stronger. A 2023 article makes a similar point for foster care. It says adults should listen to children and consider what the children say they need.
Do not compete. Do not criticize the other parent, and do not try to replace anyone. A child’s complaint is not an invitation to prove you are better than the people the child misses.
When to Worry
Most of the time, the sentence is a sore spot and not an emergency. Watch for signs of clinical depression, however, and get help from a therapist or counselor when you need it. Take it seriously, too, if a child says someone at either home is hurting them.
What to Do in the Moment
A child who says they want other parents is usually still deciding whether you will stay. You do not have to fix that grief before dinner. You can say you know, you are sorry, and you love them. Then you can keep on being the adult who is still there. In the long run, that’s the only way to convince them that we can be a family where they feel they belong.
Want to go deeper? Being the People Who Are Not Supposed to Be There covers how foster, adoptive, and stepparents can build a relationship with a child when the child did not choose them. https://www.ysoacademy.com/courses/not-supposed-to-be-there
