Everyone Loves the Tradition Except the New Kid
A tough issue this time of year is the family tradition that everyone loves except the child who joined us most recently. She may be a foster child, an adopted child, or a stepchild. She may be a child of divorce who now splits the holidays between two houses. In whatever way she has joined our family, she sits through the pie and the movie and waits for it to end.
We usually read her quiet as shyness. Sometimes it is. Other times the tradition means nothing to her yet. We love our traditions for the memories attached to them. A child who joined us last year does not share those memories. It stings when a much-loved tradition falls flat with a new child we love. We planned it, and she politely (more or less) tolerates it.
What Makes a Tradition Mean Something
There’s not a lot of research to help us navigate these awkward moments, but what we have indicates that traditions don’t really matter until we have meaning to attach to them. A 2025 survey of 755 Chinese teenagers found that the symbolic meaning of a family ritual mattered more than the activity. A second 2025 survey of 836 high school students in China linked family rituals to better friendships. Parents’ support and the teens’ sense of meaning in life explained part of that link. Both surveys measured one moment in time, so they show a link, not a cause.
In plain terms, doing the same thing every year does not make it a tradition to a child. The meaning has to reach her. A pie she has no connection to, in a house where she has lived for three months, may mean only that dessert comes after dinner.
When the Child Has No Part in It
A 2009 study asked 80 young-adult stepchildren why a parent’s remarriage ceremony felt empty to them. Their reasons included a ceremony that ignored their original family and left them without a role. That study looked at a wedding, not a holiday dinner. The complaint still sounds familiar to anyone who has watched a child sit through a tradition she had no hand in.
In most Plan B homes, the family wrote the script before the child arrived. A stepchild may join a household whose Christmas Eve routine began a decade ago. A foster child may arrive in October and meet the family’s whole holiday calendar in one season. The adults know the lines, but the child has to learn them.
Honoring the Old Family and the New One
A 1998 study interviewed 53 members of blended families about rituals that worked and rituals that failed. The rituals that worked were the ones that could “pay homage to both old and new families.” In a stepfamily, the child’s first family belongs in the day, even when the stepparent planned the rest of it.
Our other Plan B families face the same task in different forms:
- Adoptive families. A 2011 study of 22 adoptive parents describes the task of building a kinship that includes both adoptive and birth relatives. The parents did much of that work through everyday family practices.
- Foster families. A 2017 study found that foster parents saw routines as essential to family wellbeing. The authors suggest routines can build stability and a sense of belonging for children. This study was observational, not a measured result, but experienced foster parents have knowledge that we can learn form.
Ask the Child Before the Season Starts
A 2025 review of research on children in out-of-home care found that taking part in decisions about their own lives helps those children. The review covered decisions about care, but the principles would seem to apply just as well to holiday traditions.
Consider whether the following techniques would work in your family:
- Ask early and offer choices. Ask in October, not at the Thanksgiving table. Also realize that “What do you want to keep this year?” is too big a question for a child who just arrived. Offer two or three specific choices instead, such as the pie or the pancakes, or the movie or the walk.
- Explain why. Every tradition has a reason, and we rarely say it out loud. Tell her why we light the candles or why we bake the same cake. A child who knows the reason has something to attach to the day, even if she never met the person who started it.
- Recognize your kid’s first family. A stepchild’s parent can lead the traditions that belong to the two of them. The stepparent can build new ones alongside. A foster child may want to send a card, and her caseworker can tell us what contact is safe. An adopted child may want a piece of her birth family’s story in the day. A child of divorce may want one favorite recipe to move between both houses. Whatever your child’s circumstance, try to recognize where they came from.
- Change one thing, not everything. Consider adjusting one small piece each year and leaving the rest of the day alone. The familiar parts give a new child something steady, and the changed part show the day can bend to include them.
- Start one new tradition together. A new tradition has no history, so nobody owns it yet. The child can help pick the food, the music, or the place, and then can see his or her own mark on it.
- Accept a no. A child who says “skip it” has told us something useful. We can honor it this year and ask again next year.
Suppose a ten-year-old stepson joins your Thanksgiving for the first time. Your family always eats at two, plays touch football, and serves the pie before anyone clears the turkey. In October, you ask him which parts sound fun and which sound awful. He says the football sounds awful and that his mother always makes the rolls. Now you have two facts to work with, and neither one costs you the tradition.
Asking only works if we use the answer. If he says the football sounds awful, we cannot keep it mandatory and call that a choice. I suspect a child who learns that his or her answers change nothing will stop giving them. It may also sting when our child turns down something we love. That reaction is reasonable. The no may be about the football and nothing else. Sometimes it is about something larger, and we can ask about that later, when our kid is not on the spot.
What a Good Tradition Does
A tradition earns its place at our table when the new kid can find him or herself in it. That process can take years. Some years our kids will still sit through the movie and wait for it to end. Keep asking them what they want anyway.
Want to go deeper? Our online course, Becoming the Mentor in Our Child’s Story, shows foster, adoptive, and stepparents how to guide a child’s story without taking over.
